If I could go back in time for an hour or two, it wouldn’t be to have a meaningful conversation with my dead grandparents. No. I would use that opportunity to flip through late ‘90s catalogs from Delia*s, Sears Wish Book, YM, and of course the American Girl catalog.
American Girls were fictional 9-year-olds from different eras in American history, like pioneer times, the Edwardian era, and the Great Depression. Each character was sold as an 18-inch doll and had six corresponding books: tales of going to school, celebrating holidays, learning valuable life lessons, etc. The books showed illustrations of them in various period-appropriate items like a pinafore or pantalettes, which you could purchase for your dolls. Some of the girls slayed more than others.
I was fortunate enough to have two: Josefina (whose hair I took out of the braid and ruined) and Kit. But I was mostly in it for the books. I think I checked out every single AG book from the library. The dolls’ stories — sanitized and Eurocentric like much of American history — touched on poverty, immigration, slavery, child labor, parental loss, racism, and war.
For almost 20 years, Addy was the only Black AG doll. They’ve since added others like Melody from 1960s Detroit and Cecile living in 1850s New Orleans. Despite the brand’s shortcomings, I bet they got a lot of children interested in history for the first time.
You may also remember the parent company’s other iconic offerings like Bitty Baby and the generation-defining The Care and Keeping of You book (you know the page I’m talking about).
I wanted to give context for straight men and anyone outside the States since I’m not sure the dolls ever crossed over. Now, for a more shallow look at American Girl. I want to talk about who had the best outfits! I’m only including the historical dolls released through 2001. That was my era.
I do love my grandparents btw.
Josefina Montoya
Josefina was my number-one. She’s a Mexican girl living in 1824 New Mexico before it was part of the U.S. Chill demeanor, three older sisters, dead mom, beautiful hoop earrings. Josefina doesn’t bother anyone. She wants to be a healer and springs into action to treat a friend’s snake bite. Josefina loves chocolate. She bakes bread in an outdoor oven. Hmm much of what I remember from the books is food-related.
I like her looks, which often consist of a simple blouse, skirt, and sash. Her accessories are what do it for me, like the yellow primroses in her hair, stunning turquoise silk shoes, embroidered shawl, bolero vest, and black lace mantilla.
Did she have the best clothes? No. She always looked beautiful but had her mind on other things, like grief. Fashion was not her priority.
Felicity Merriman
Felicity is a horse girl tomboy from 1770s colonial Williamsburg. I don’t remember much about her, I guess the Revolutionary War didn’t do it for me as a kid. She’s spunky because she’s a redhead, duh. She once made apple butter, and I've wanted apple butter ever since. She learned the proper way to serve tea because that's what girls’ education was back then.
Her style is Dôen/Reformation-ish to me. Dainty floral prints. The rich gold & green riding outfit is luxe and regal but she literally looks like she’s going to war? Maybe she was! My husband identified her headwear as a “tricorn hat” off the top of his head. What is it with men and warfare.
I absolutely love Felicity’s blue Christmas look (it’s Ramona Blue) but my faves are the pink dress & floral apron and the airy white summer dress with a straw hat. One too many bonnets for me, but accurate to the period.
Did she have the best clothes? No. Like Taylor Swift, her shoes often ruin her fits.
Molly McIntire
Molly lives in 1944 Illinois with her mom and siblings while her father’s stationed in England caring for wounded soldiers. She’s basically what got me into WWII (we all had a favorite war growing up and I’m basic). Molly has home front hobbies like growing a victory garden and collecting scrap metal for the army. I had a complicated relationship with her because I wore glasses at the time and projected my self-loathing onto her.
I was soooo relieved and jealous in the final book when she’s dressed as Miss Victory for her tap recital with curled hair and no specs. Another standout moment is when Molly’s mom saves up enough sugar rations to bake a chocolate cake for her birthday. Again, food!
The Miss Victory costume is wonderful, but feels a little too overtly patriotic for me under the current administration. Instead, I’d steal her striped pajamas with the matching hair ribbons. Her Meet outfit is also classic, j’adore the beret.
Did she have the best clothes? No. Molly might be in last place for me.
Addy Walker
It’s 1864. Addy and her mother flee a southern plantation and make their way to Philadelphia. Addy has the cutest face of the dolls and the most harrowing backstory. She watches her dad and brother get sold to another plantation, she escapes slavery, lives apart from her loved ones, is the only person in her family who knows how to read, and endures plenty more trauma as a Black American during the Civil War.
Outfits-wise, Addy and her mom work in a dress shop so fit and fabric are never an issue. Her yellow-and-black checked birthday outfit is adorable. That tartan Christmas dress is gorgeous, and I have a pink-and-white striped dress from Sézane that’s similar to her “Meet Addy” look. I love her hair bows and hats and that she has a gap in her teeth like me. Pretty shell necklace too. And how lovely is that white rosette sash on her red dress.
Did she have the best clothes? Addy has zero bad outfits. But there’s a doll with higher highs, IMO.
Kirsten Larson
Kirsten is a pioneer girl who immigrates from Sweden to Minnesota in 1854. If you liked Little House on the Prairie books, you were probably also into Kirsten. Her stories were some of my favorites because I had a misguided longing to live in a drafty log cabin in the middle of nowhere and attend a one-room schoolhouse.
But Minnesota winters weren’t her greatest stress. No. Kirsten’s best friend Marta dies of cholera in book one while making the journey to America. Kirsten learns how to speak English and adjusts to life in a new country. She has to do farm work. She’s isolated.
In terms of clothing, it’s all about Kiki’s Saint Lucia outfit in honor of the Nordic celebration that kicks off Christmastime. She rocks the white gown and an evergreen crown with candles in it. So dramatic. She and her mom bake some delicious-looking Saint Lucia buns. Why didn’t I make this post about American Girl doll food!!
Kirsten also has a precious Midsommar-looking pink dress and daisy crown, and I like the red leather boots she pairs with her winter look.
Did she have the best clothes? It’s hard to make an apron chic. She did her best but she’s not my top choice. I’ll award her best hair for those iconic looped braids.
Kit Kittredge
Kit is living through the Great Depression in Ohio. Her dad loses his job and she sees him in line at a soup kitchen. Her mom runs a boardinghouse out of their home, and taught me that cutting sandwiches diagonally makes them look bigger. Kit is a budding journalist who writes her own newspaper. She likes baseball. She’s not a girly girl.
She has some cute items in her collection, and that bitchy bob doesn’t hurt. Her Meet sweater set is very Drew Barrymore in Never Been Kissed. Love.
See that green dress? Kit’s aunt makes it for her out of a chicken-feed sack. And her sailor pajamas!! She looks like Sutton Foster in Anything Goes. But my number-one Kit look is the overalls and newsboy cap. Effortlessly cool. She’d probably wear Alex Mill in 2025.
Did she have the best clothes? Close. Kit’s got the range, especially for someone facing economic uncertainty.
Samantha Parkington
Samantha has it all. Except parents, famously. She’s an orphan living in New York state in 1904. She lost her parents to a boating accident when she was five and is raised by her wealthy grandma, who she calls Grandmary. How chic is that.
Aside from the catastrophic loss of her mom and dad, Sam had it relatively easy in life. Her main struggle in the books isn’t even her own. It’s her friend Nellie’s, a child laborer whose parents die of the flu and who goes to live in an abusive orphanage. Sam’s biggest problems are things like, “oh no, I lost that game of croquet.” This basically sums her up:
I love her clothing. I love her thick shiny mane and satin hair ribbons. Her Meet dress may be the most iconic American Girl dress ever made. The fur hat and muff that complement her winter coat? Fancy fancy. For tea time, she’s dressed like a prissy little pastry. LoveShackFancy/Zimmermann vibes. Not necessarily my style but she looks darling in everything.
Samantha has a butterfly-catching dress! So aspirational. So unserious.
Did she have the best clothes? I’m sorry but yes. I know no one was rooting for her. She’s the richest of the gals so she better bring it!!
Please tell me which doll has your favorite attire. Oh and ICYMI, sorry to inform you there is now a “historical” American Girl doll from the late ‘90s with inflatable furniture. At least she looks cool as hell.
Not done yet!!
Baba Wawa documentary
This week, I watched Barbara Walters: Tell Me Everything on Disney+. I’m a big fan of The View historically (less so lately) and grew up on her primetime interviews.
Barbara’s a trailblazer for women in journalism, but complicated, like many successful people. She was besties with Roy Cohn?? 😳 She had an affair with a married senator. She said to Katie Couric, “We're so alike: Neither of us is that attractive.” 😳
But she nabbed a lot of big interviews over her male competitors. She was ahead of the curve in believing that celebrities are news, for better or worse. In the ‘70s, she confronted the Shah of Iran over his misogyny. The doc is worth a watch.
The Gwyneth book
Amy Odell’s Gwyneth Paltrow biography was released on Tuesday and I woke up like it was Christmas morning. I’m going to read Braiding Sweetgrass next to take a break from rotting my brain.
Gwyneth is another complicated blonde. She’s repeatedly described as luminous. Journalists walk in wanting to hate her and leave wishing to be her best friend. She’s got influence, connections, charisma, and talent. She’s a nepo baby completely disconnected from normal life. One on one, GP makes a great impression (except on Goop employees), but constantly puts her foot in her mouth during interviews.
The first half has more insider info, stuff I didn’t know. Once you get to her Chris Martin era, it’s essentially a chronological collection of tabloid stories with some Goop goss. The juiciest thing I learned is that she stole her daughter’s name from Peter Farrelly, who directed her in Shallow Hal. He named his daughter Apple first!
Odell makes a convincing case that Goop’s pseudoscience is a pipeline to RFK Jr. and MAHA. Sure, food industry lobbying = bad, too much ultra-processed food = bad, lack of nutrition education = bad, but I can’t get down with vaccine misinformation and the anti-fluoride stuff and firing the experts who don't agree with his conspiracy theories. Oops, tangent.
Anyway, Gwen’s an out-of-touch weirdo. Highly recommend Shakespeare in Love if you haven’t seen it though!














Samantha's trunk/bedroom set and her wicker dining set!!!! I still dream of her beautiful nightgown. Those magazines were so special and I remember sitting for hours looking at the beautiful details. The new stuff is just so sad and plastic. I still have Samantha, Kirsten (f'd up one braid and it ruined my life), Addy and Felicity in almost perfect condition. My mom kept them awaiting the day I might have a kid that would want to play with them. My daughter is turning 8 soon - the time has finally come. Ha! Watch and she takes all the hairdos out. LOL
Molly stan here. Actually I think it's because she wore glasses and me too and I was already looking for relatability when I was 8. That aside, it was always Kirsten's St. Lucia getup that did it for me. Never read any of her books though.